Skip to the line
ninja line
Butter Stick Squishy Toys, 2-Pack by ninja line — set up between two trees

Indoor hand play

Butter Stick Squishy Toys, 2-Pack

$15.99Back shortly

4.8 out of 5 from 44 write-ups on our product listing

A squishy shaped like a stick of butter is a joke that keeps working. Press one and it takes its time coming back, which is the part that makes it hard to put down. Every pack has both colours, one red swirl and one blue, so there is always a second one to hand over instead of an argument.

Why it is built this way

What you are getting

  • Slow rising, soft PU foamSqueeze, and the shape returns over a few seconds. It is the pace that makes it a fidget rather than a bouncy toy.
  • Tested, with the paperworkChildren's Product Certificate on file, tested to applicable ASTM F963-23 requirements and CPSIA lead and phthalate limits.
  • Both colours, every packRed swirl and blue, fixed pair. Nobody opens the box and finds two of the same.
  • Sized for one handAbout 5.5 inches long and 1.6 inches square — a comfortable grip for a child, small enough to live in a coat pocket.

The numbers

Specification
Pieces2
ColoursRed swirl and blue
MaterialSoft PU foam
Size5.51 x 1.57 x 1.57 in
SafetyCPC certified, ASTM F963-23 tested
Ages3 and up

Written by the people who rigged it

What people wrote about the Butter Stick Squishy Toys, 2-Pack

Unedited, from the write-ups on our product listing.

4.5out of 5 across the write-ups below
  • 5★1
  • 4★1
  • 3★0
  • 2★0
  • 1★0

★★★★☆

More unique than your typical butter squishie.

Squishies are ALL the rage right now! My kids are constantly collecting and trading these, so I wanted to get them something unique. I like these variations because they are basically stress balls, the kids just don't know it. These are made of a foam like material instead of those water / gel filled ones that kids are getting hurt with. These are VERY slow rise, if you are impatient, it can be almost annoying how very slow these are so just keep that in mind. I wouldn't say that necessarily a bad thing it just depends on what you, personally, are looking for. Overall I like them, decent value, great for kids or adults.

Erica G. · September 6, 2026

★★★★★

FUN

Colorful and fun to squish! My students enjoyed it before handwriting tasks.

tracy · August 27, 2026

Asked at the fence

About the Butter Stick Squishy Toys, 2-Pack

Is it safe for a three-year-old?

It is rated for ages 3+ and holds a Children's Product Certificate. It is made for squeezing and kneading, not for biting or pulling apart.

How slowly does it rise?

A few seconds from a full squeeze. Warm hands speed it up slightly.

Can I choose the colours?

The pair is fixed — one red swirl and one blue in every pack.

Also on the strap

The rest of the line

Ready to string it up?

Pick the gap in your garden, pick the length that fits it, and let the rest be worked out by whoever is hanging upside down at the time.